How Subjective Is Maturity? Understanding Emotional Growth
Written on
Chapter 1: Defining Maturity
The topic of emotional maturity often arises in heated exchanges, be it during childhood disputes or disagreements between partners. Phrases like "You're acting immature!" or "You lack the emotional depth to grasp my situation!" are commonplace. Many people tend to dismiss others based on their perceived level of maturity. Psychologists delve into whether this trait is innate or learned, pondering the impact of hormones like testosterone and estrogen in these dynamics. Furthermore, how should we engage with those who seem to defy conventional maturity norms?
Maturity in Context
In a stimulating article from January, Dr. Tony Dionys challenges the assumption that one gender is inherently more mature than the other. He highlights that society has come to recognize women's capabilities in fields such as science, mathematics, and technology. Similarly, he argues that men possess equal potential for maturity, compassion, and vulnerability. The distinction lies in systemic influences that shape these traits.
Girls are increasingly breaking through historical barriers that have limited their opportunities to demonstrate their capabilities. In contrast, boys often encounter a different set of societal pressures that discourage them from expressing a full range of human emotions.
Maturity Characteristics
The gender-based differences in emotional expression lead to the archetype of the "emotionally mature man" often feeling out of reach. In a past article, James Michael Sama identified several key traits that signify emotional maturity, including self-awareness, integrity, generosity, patience, and keen observation. While the debate over nature versus nurture may persist indefinitely, it’s evident that certain maturity indicators are valuable in all individuals, irrespective of gender. Traits such as collaboration, time management, empathy, and inclusivity are universally esteemed.
Evaluating Maturity
Despite our desire for a definitive standard for assessing maturity, who would be qualified to make such judgments? In the comments section of Dr. Dionys's article, Elisa Mariño shares her perspective that emotional maturity can be self-taught. She notes that individuals, regardless of gender, may not be expected to exhibit emotional maturity uniformly across different contexts. For instance, a person's behavior at home may differ significantly from their demeanor in a professional setting.
When June Kirri remarked that observations indicate girls often mature faster than boys, I asked her to consider how much of this observation is rooted in biological versus cultural factors. Her response suggested a blend of both influences.
This brings us back to the initial inquiry: How do personal biases shape our perception of another's behavior as "mature"? If someone appears simplistic or superficial to us, how accurately can we gauge their inner motivations or struggles?
Considering that maturity can often be a self-directed journey born of necessity, how well are we equipping ourselves with the skills to cope with the flaws of those around us? Given the myriad of traumas, burdens, and emotional challenges individuals face, is it justifiable to label someone as "immature" or "entitled," especially based solely on their gender?
The first video, "How 'mature' are you? How do you judge emotional+psychological 'maturity'?" explores the various aspects of emotional maturity and how it can be perceived differently based on societal norms and personal experiences.
Chapter 2: Cultural Influences on Maturity
In the quest to understand maturity, we must consider how societal expectations shape our views.
The second video, "Budoshin Jujitsu: Episode 77: Black Belt Subjective Criteria - Part 1," discusses the subjective nature of criteria for personal growth and achievement, relevant to understanding maturity's complexities.